Proposed coding standards change (always require braces)

Our current PHP coding standards specify that for if statements, “single line blocks can omit braces for brevity.” All other constructs “should always contain braces as this enhances readability, and allows for fewer line edits for debugging or additional functionality later.” I’d like to propose we always require braces for all blocks.

One could argue about coding standards all day (not in this comments thread), but allowing braces to be omitted is probably the only thing in our standards that can cause legitimate problems, like making it easier to introduce errors. It also makes code more annoying to patchpatch A special text file that describes changes to code, by identifying the files and lines which are added, removed, and altered. It may also be referred to as a diff. A patch can be applied to a codebase for testing. and less maintainable, and requires larger diffs. And, it’s more work to debug code, as you have to add braces to add debugging lines, then remove them when done. It’s easy to attempt to add a new line inside the conditional and screw it up, which has occurred even a few times in the last few weeks. For example:

if ( some_conditional() )
    return some_function();

Another catalyst here is our new JavaScript standards. Due to multi-line chaining and other situations, it is basically insane to omit curly braces in JavaScriptJavaScript JavaScript or JS is an object-oriented computer programming language commonly used to create interactive effects within web browsers. WordPress makes extensive use of JS for a better user experience. While PHP is executed on the server, JS executes within a user’s browser. It would be nice if our standards matched, making this the right time to raise the issue for PHPPHP The web scripting language in which WordPress is primarily architected. WordPress requires PHP 5.6.20. Our coding standards have a general emphasis on whitespace and readability, and the lack of braces do generally make code feel lighter and easier to scan, but I think we’ve reached a breaking point. I’ve surveyed the other lead developers and the consensus was that while omitting braces is elegant, it doesn’t best serve the needs of the project (with many people editing many things often).

I’d like to discuss this during today’s meeting, and ideally make a decision.

I will mention that adopting this will mean all new code will receive braces. We can discuss what to do with existing code. Please don’t waste any time on a patch to add braces manually; we’d script it and do it in one commit if that’s the route we decide to take. (There’s more than 8,000 structures lacking braces.) Also worth reading in preparation for a discussion is a section in Linux’s contributor documentation on coding style pitfalls, something I’ve linked to before.

P.S. This wouldn’t change bracing placement. It’s still like this:

function func_name() {
    if ( some_conditional() ) {
        echo "Braces shall be 'cuddled,' not pushed to the next line."
    } else {
        echo "For all control structures.";

Update: This proposal was accepted during the Wednesday meeting. I’ve updated the coding standards handbook page. We’ve yet to discuss what we’ll do for old code, but all new and changed code should receive braces.