Hey everyone I just wanted to introduce myself…

Hey everyone, I just wanted to introduce myself, and give you all an update on the spam video submissions.

I recently joined the Dot Org team at Automattic, and part of my role is to help maintain WordPress.tv. One of my first projects was to look at solutions to the spam problem.

I added a simple honeypot to the submit form about a month ago to try and catch bots, but it hasn’t been very successful. It looks like most of the spam that’s being submitted is being done manually by actual people, which makes it much harder to catch programmatically.

So, I’ll be working on a more robust approach over the next few weeks that will hopefully cut down on it, but it’s likely that we’ll always have to deal with a certain amount.

I’d also like to suggest a couple tweaks to the review process that I think would be helpful with regards to these submissions:

  • Instead of using the “spam” tag for these posts, the “public-spam” one would be better. There are some legitimate videos related to (combatting) spam that already use the “spam” tag, so using a different tag will help keep those separated from the spam submissions.
  • Moving the posts to TrashTrash Trash in WordPress is like the Recycle Bin on your PC or Trash in your Macintosh computer. Users with the proper permission level (administrators and editors) have the ability to delete a post, page, and/or comments. When you delete the item, it is moved to the trash folder where it will remain for 30 days. (but not permanently deleting them), would make it obvious that it’s already been reviewed and would prevent them from cluttering up the legitimate pending posts.

I’ve got through and done those two things for all the existing posts.

I’ll also post another update once the next solution is in place.

#spam

Not everyone has nice things to say..

Not a real person.

Not a real person.

Howdy mods, just a quick note to mods to be careful (and think twice) about the comments you approve. One went up on the site recently was pretty suspect.

Telltale signs? Aside from the Funny Star Wars name and a openly critical comment, the email address the commenter used was a big red flag. Remember, we want to do everything in our power to foster useful and constructive community discussions and some comments don’t exactly do that.

The following are the kinds of comments we do not want to approve. When in doubt ask an experienced mod to make the judgement call.

  1. Comments that don’t further the discussion on the topic
  2. Comments critical of video/audio quality – They just don’t help
  3. Comments that are derogatory in nature, toward the speaker or the presentation – Differing viewpoints (when presented respectfully) are OK, be anyone being an obvious troll is not.
  4. Comments that use a spammy-sounding name, spammy (or fake) email address, or spammy website link should not be approved. Even if the comments appear to be legitimate, if any of the above are true, it’s spam.

When in doubt, trust your gut, if a comment looks fishy for any reason, well, it probably is. 🙂

#comments, #spam