I have just published a guide to reviewing Themes for the WordPress Theme Repository, which will hopefully offer some guidance for all of our wonderful new review team volunteers.
Note: I published the guide on my personal site, rather than here on the official WPTRT site, because I want to emphasize that the guide is not official. Each reviewer is welcome to develop his or her own style and process.
I also made some updates to the Theme Review and Theme Unit Test Codex pages. I discovered some needed changes as I was working through writing the tutorial.
Arnold 3:51 am on April 21, 2011 Permalink
I wanted to comment on your site but unfortunately these ‘old’ eyes cannot read your ‘captcha’. You have taken a somewhat complicated topic and turned it into something simple to understand, well done. This is definitely going to be valuable to a ‘newbie’ like myself.